I'm pretty hard on boots I guess. I used to wear Red Wing Loggers pretty much all the time. The last couple pairs lasted less then a year each before they had serious problems. The boot shop owner said hed had a lot of problems recently (was several years ago). He suggested upgrading to the Hathorn Smoke Jumpers, which I did, with my full credit refund from the last Red wings I got, and added another hundred dollars to. They fit well, though were rough breaking in the first few weeks. I use the $20 version of the Spenco impact insoles, and I don't think I've ever had as tough and comfortable of a boot, ever. I managed to abuse and wear out one set of lowers (besides a resole in the middle) and had them factory rebuilt. They did an outstanding job, and I love my Hathorns. I can be on my feet all day long working or walking and not have tired feet.
I have a pair of the Danner Pronghorns, made in Cheena. They are good, but not great. Not nearly as comfortable as the Hathorns, and not rebuildable in the same way. I'm not overly impressed with the overall quality, longevity, or feel. Other models may be better, besides being US made which may help.
At this point, if I bought a different boot than the Hathorns for general hard use, it would be Whites.