Overland Expo West in new mag

There's a big difference.

In every activity/subculture I've been a member of there was always a cool kid group and entry into the group was dependent on owning the "group standard" equipment, clothing, gear, vehicles...whatever. Sometimes the stuff was top notch and useful, sometimes it was stupid, nearly always it was expensive. :D
Truth spoken here...
 
I didn't think people still read print magazines, particularly those that seem to tailor their articles to advertising budgets from the companies' product they are testing. Just once I'd like to read that XXX product sucks the big weenie, not worth the packaging it comes in!:rolleyes:

Bob,

I think I'd have gone with ABC product for that particular sentence. You lost me for a second. :eek:
 
Just once I'd like to read that XXX product sucks the big weenie, not worth the packaging it comes in!:rolleyes:
I agree advertorial is definitely a problem, and there's a ton of "because the advertiser said so" out there being peddled as independent testing. There are some legitimate reasons you don't see overwhelmingly negative reviews though. Most of the experienced gear gurus can tell if a product will be complete garbage before even receiving it, and will instead put their efforts into sourcing products that are more worthy of airtime. Sometimes, especially with long-term reviews, the product is actually the author's own personal gear and was chosen with only performance in mind.

Another reason we avoid a good flaming is if we rip into manufacturer A's product because it's complete garbage, even if it's completely true, manufacturer B will be much more hesitant to have us review their product, even if they agreed with us. Most magazines don't have the budget to go buy everything they test outright, and so have to rely on the good will of manufacturers to get free or pro-dealed product for testing.

Unfortunately, there's no way to know for sure that a magazine is on the level until they throw someone under the bus, and even then...
 
Back
Top Bottom