Damn,
@jscusmcvet, do I detect a note of butt-hurt? John, nobody expects you go run out and start buying "bling-covery" gear to compete with the "bolt-ons on their bolt-ons" crowd. I also know you aren't new to this activity either, but I will educate you to make the wisest purchase you can and make the best of your treasure, while not cutting corners in order to be safe. Sorry if I hurt your feelings by suggesting better equipment or if I gave you cause to think you just fell off the pumpkin cart. I know you're an old gungy bastard. Big hug, buddy.
@Mr. Leary, Mike, I've never seen one fail either, and thanks for adding that observation. To amplify my recommendation to John, I trust my mentors - more learned users/experience that they have, totaling nearly a combined century that goes well beyond recreational trail riding, and trust empirical lab tests that indicate they will fail sooner than the one illustrated below. My observations, or
@Dave's, aren't based on my/our personal experience necessarily, but rather on training, education, demonstration, testing, and certification from a well-developed curriculum. Which is why I referred you to Scott and Mike whom I regard as some of the best in the industry, and in your back yard, who wouldn't hesitate to "hook you up." That's where I'm coming from - to let you know - I'm not getting jack-squat from recommending safe practices or good equipment, except the knowledge that if you choose to accept it you and your passengers might be safer and there will be one less statistic to report. I could have just as easily ignored your post... but I didn't because you're on this forum and you trust we will give you honesty in return.
Take this image of a hook. This is a perfectly acceptable piece of kit, not as safe as a closed system, but none-the-less tried and true and providing reliable service since JC started working high-steel. Note the broad shoulders of the slip hook that better support a steel screw-pin recovery shackle, recovery pulley, or the folded eye loops of a strap that further wrap around to protect the safety gate pin from damage. What you can't see are the cast in ratings or certification of the hook. There are other low-cost thimbles that are milled from Aluminum. All of which are independently tested to failure and certified for specific loads greater than you will likely ever apply. Or, go with the one not tested or certified from the lowest bidder to meet a price point of a consumer who doesn't know the difference. My point is get smart on this stuff and you can have a perfectly reliable, safe, and economic recovery system that will give you a lifetime of service. Or, just ignore my advice - your call buddy. I'll still join you on the trail... I'll just stand farther away.
Like the saying goes, "friends don't let friends drink bad coffee."