911 Cell calls

bob91yj

Adventurist
Founding Member
Straight up jacked this from the other forum, OP (screen name there is Jelf) said it was cool to share...

I am a software developer working with online maps and location technology. Earlier this year I became interested in what happens when someone with a cell phone calls 911. In particular I wanted to know the details of how the 911 dispatcher learns the *location* of the caller. What kind of digital magic happens behind the scenes?

Much of what I learned came from reviewing documents on the FCC’s website. On one hand I learned that the FCC requires a wireless carrier handling a 911 call to produce coordinates for the caller’s location. Sounds good, right? On the other hand I learned that many carriers have exempted themselves from this requirement over large portions of the area they serve. I also learned that the coordinate accuracy most of us easily get on our smartphones (or handheld GPS) is often 10 times more accurate - or more - than the coordinates produced by the wireless carrier handling a 911 call.

Recently I finished a report that shares what I learned. That report consists of:
1. A list of tips for calling 911 with a cell phone.
2. Background information so you understand the big picture.
3. Detailed information to support each tip.
For those wishing to dig into the source material for themselves, the report includes links to various documents on the FCC website.

I posted a copy of this report on my server at
https://mappingsupport.com/p/sar/cal...cell-phone.pdf

Here are the tips. I am happy to answer questions.

--- Tip #1 ---
If you need to call 911 and your cell phone shows ‘no service’, then you should call 911 anyway and let it ring 45-60 seconds before hanging up.

--- Tip #2 ---
You should give the 911 dispatcher your location by providing (1) a street address, or (2) a verbal description the dispatcher understands, or (3) your latitude longitude coordinates expressed as decimal degrees.

--- Tip #3 ---
FindMeSAR is a browser app that was developed as a public service specifically to provide an easy and ‘no cost’ way for anyone with a smartphone to display their coordinates and accuracy value while their phone is either online or offline. This is not a commercial product of any kind. It is a volunteer project just to try and help people when they need help.

--- Tip #4 ---
When you call 911 with a cell phone the wireless carrier handling the call might not produce *any* coordinates for your location.

--- Tip #5 ---
Even if the wireless carrier handling your 911 call does produce coordinates for your location, the coordinates you can obtain from your smartphone are either (1) more accurate or (2) a lot more accurate than the coordinates produced by the wireless carrier.

--- Tip #6 ---
If (1) your phone is not within range of a cell tower and (2) your phone does not have a current copy of the satellite ‘assistance’ data, then it will take 15 to 20 minutes before your phone will produce coordinates for your location.

--- Tip #7 ---
No one is monitoring the wireless carriers to see whether or not they are in compliance with the standards and requirements that the FCC has adopted regarding wireless calls to 911 and coordinate data for the caller’s location.

--- Tip #8 ---
If you have an android phone then to get the most accurate coordinates set the location mode (or method) to “GPS only”.

--- Tip #9 ---
If you have an Android phone then there is a free and easy way to find out if your phone can produce more accurate coordinates by using data from both the USA satellites (GPS) and the Russian satellites (GLONASS).

--- Tip #10 ---
Phones that have no service plan at all can still (1) call 911 and (2) run an app that displays coordinates and accuracy on the phone’s screen.

--- Tip #11 ---
If at all possible, make a voice call to 911 instead of texting.

--- Tip #12 ---
If you do text to 911, then the dispatcher is most likely not going to have *any* location data for you unless you include it in your text.

--- Tip #13 ---
After you contact 911 take steps to make your phone’s battery last as long as possible.

Joseph
 
If a phone doesn't submit coordinates it will show a radius off of whatever tower it goes through. And not all 911 call centers can even receive text messages, so I wouldn't put all my eggs in that basket.

https://www.smart911.com/ register here, if you're going on a trip add some info before you go. Once again not all call centers can access this info, but if they can it could make a big difference.
 
Also note that sometimes the GPS data that dispatch gets is a triangulation to your approximate position using as many cell towers as you have in contact with you. That can be off (in my personal experience as a former full time police officer) up to a couple of miles! When giving locations it helps to describe what your location looks like. As unites respond, possibly running code, it is easy to pass an obscure address, dirt road or even a well marked residence. If you have a spare person during a critical incident then send them to the main road/driveway/etc to help wave down responders.

Cell phone boosters/amplifiers (like the Wilson I run in the family adventure van) will skew your position due to (often) only talking to a single tower and using a signal more powerful than a typical handheld device. Specific GPS coordinates are good in these cases. Even if the responding unites don't have the ability to enter a GPS waypoint, dispatch can and will give directions to the responding units. This is also true if not using a booster but just being far away.
 
If you have a spare person during a critical incident then send them to the main road/driveway/etc to help wave down responders.

Absolutely do this - self-help if possible........They can't help you if they can't find you . . . .

Emergency services have varying levels of sophistication and training, and no matter how good they are, nobody gets it right every time.

I was involved in a rescue situation in the United Arab Emirates where we had intermittent cell coverage. We we were able to get coordinates to the local police dept, but it took them five hours to find someone who could work the equipment and tell them how to find us. Try explaining the difference between position formats on a cell phone with a dying battery to someone who barely speaks your language. They eventually got a helicopter involved because the pilots were the only ones who had the skills to operate the GPS.

This is not just the case in other countries. A few years ago, I was in a head-on collision about 500 yards from the river that separates Fulton County Ga. from Cobb County Ga. I was in the City of Atlanta on the east side of the river. But my phone was hitting a cell tower on the west side of the river in Cobb County. The Cobb County 911 operator was unable to help me, transfer me, or alert the Fulton County operator (She tried to call them on another line, but couldn't get through). Her advice was to hang up and call directory assistance for the Atlanta Fire Dept. We eventually got help by sending a runner to a nearby fire station to ask for help. 45 minutes after that station responded, a truck arrived from another (further) station in response to the 911 call.

The moral of the story, is help yourself and the EMS folks as much as possible. Don't sit there bleeding while you wait on the computers and IT architecture to solve the problem for you.

(on a related note, if you are ever in a head-on collision, be the guy in the dump truck, and not the drunk in the oldsmobile.)
 
Back
Top Bottom